I've pretty much ruled out the Sig Mosquito and the Walther P22. The Walther on the other hand features their now-standard eccentric pattern molded into the frame itself. Shop for Ruger Sr22 Vs Lcp 380 And Walther P22 22lr Pistol Vs Ruger Sr22 Ads Immediately . Said another way, your goals and preferences might not look like my goals and preferences. The trigger on the Walther is entirely superior to the Ruger, even in double action mode. Rather, they were on the corners where they did little good. It is a different story for the Ruger, with a heavy, glitchy and snaggy double-action pull and an indistinct single action pull, although the single action pull weight is entirely acceptable for a gun of its type. Walther’s P22 was, at the time of its introduction, a paradigm-shifting handgun that has been copied often since its introduction and now enjoys some modern updates moving closer to its two decade mark. 2 front sight, the gun shot just above the point of aim at 15 yards, which is what we wanted. The Ruger fits my hands better than the m&p. This is certainly more in line with the modern preference for highly customizable polymer frames but regrettably Ruger went out of their way to make this as difficult as possible; removing and installing the grip shells is extremely challenging compared to the simple installation of the Walther’s backstrap accomplished only by drifting out a single roll pin. Neither. (Ruger warned against match ammo in the gun’s instruction manual.) You can lower the hammer by grasping it firmly with thumb and index finger on its sides, and pressing the trigger. That’s the weak point of this design, because you need a “tool” in the form of a slave rod to capture the spring before you can reassemble the gun. In general, you want to use some fairly stout loads to ensure good function, as it is possible to go with lighter and lighter loads, especially match loads, and see regular malfunctions. One may compare, contrast and analyze any two guns, or any number of guns that have any set of features against each other in quest of reaching a conclusion. Compare the dimensions and specs of Walther P22 Q and Walther P99 AS Now, here is where things take a turn for the interesting: The examples of the Ruger SR22 that I have shot consistently turn in better groupings across a variety of different brands of ammo than the comparative Walther P22Q examples. Posted by 1 year ago. Nov 9, 2014 #1/75 I am in the market for a .22 pistol for some inexpensive plinking. Using CCI Mini-Mag, one of my favorite all around .22 LR loads, I was obtaining 10-shot, 25 yard groups averaging 2.8” with the Walthers and 2.2” with the Rugers. We did this a number of times and that took care of some of the creep. However, both guns refused to reliably function with Federal’s Classic High Velocity ammo, and with our final match-ammo test. Feb 5, 2012 #1 Witch would you buy? you pull back on the slide, lift it, and slip it off the barrel to the front. Hey guys i'm thinking about purchasing a .22 for target practice and i'm caught between these two models. Ruger SR22 v the Walther P22. Pushing the safety down into the on-safe position does safely decock the hammer, however. Also they hold 12 rounds instead of 10 which is kind of nice. The Walther did not reliably cycle the Federal Gold Medal Match, and had one failure to feed with the Eley Ten-X. How does it … The rear sight is adjustable for windage with elevation being adjusted by replacing the front sight with one of several included various heights. Removing the original sight was easy by poking it out with a screwdriver from the inside, with the gun being disassembled. Hey Everyone! Also check out the Ruger 22/45. Go. The Ruger fits my hands better than the m&p. Sig Mosquito vs Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22 Thread starter alan226; Start date Nov 9, 2014; 1; 2; 3; Next. It's certainly not a gun that you'll be able to shoot 1" groupings with (like the Buckmark) but is is a nice little pinker. alan226. Which is better for general plinking? Thumb cocking either gun was not easy, the Ruger being harder to cock. In those firearms,... Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. The sights are plastic, the front bearing a numeral 3, and the rear having a windage adjustment. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. Shop for Ruger Sr22 Vs Lcp 380 And Walther P22 22lr Pistol Vs Ruger Sr22 Ads Immediately . We thought that was entirely adequate. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. Walther makes it easy to install a silencer-threaded barrel where those are legal. Both are entirely functional, and have only minor gripes associated with them. Took my SR22 to the range with a 525 round box ammo. Either is probably deserving of your money depending on your preferences, but my vote goes to the Walther. Die Walther P22 ist eine Selbstladepistole des deutschen Waffenherstellers Walther im Kaliber .22 lfB.. Vom Aussehen ähnelt sie der Pistole Walther P99, unterscheidet sich aber von dieser insofern deutlich, da sie über einen außenliegenden Hahn und eine manuelle Sicherung verfügt.. Technik. We suspect Walther could modify this setup to match that use by Ruger, to eliminate the need for the slave rod. Do they have any practical differences beyond the maker’s mark? Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger LCP II and Walther P22 Q re: Ruger SR22 vs S&W MP22 vs Walther P22 Posted by Sea Hoss on 10/6/16 at 2:16 pm to SpeckledTiger I haven't had any feed issues or FTE issues on my SR22. Has … On the range we encountered perhaps the most damning thing about the Ruger, its trigger. Lastly, I would be remiss if I did not mention disassembly. A few differences that might make a shooter’s decision one way or the other is the configuration of the safety and the grip options. On the subject of defensive use, which is not as surprising as you might think when discussing a .22 caliber semi, both guns could certainly fit the bill, although I have reservations about each of them. The trick in operating safeties of this nature is swiping the extended, raised thumb down and past the safety to pop it forward and up to the fire position, much more easily accomplished thanks to the small size of this gun. I bought a Ruger SR22 and decided I really like this class of handgun: tacti-cool 22 autoloaders. The average improvement in group sizes obtainable with the Ruger, fired from a heavily supported benchrest position, were anywhere from 25 to 33% better than equivalent groups fired in the Walther. Again the same thing happened with the Ruger. And hope I'm a section of assisting you to get a much better product. Walther P22 or Ruger SR22. Resident HK evangelist. Where the rubber meets the road for a pistol is always in how it shoots, and little else. Some 22 LR ammo with slower-burning powder works extremely well in rifles, but not so well in short-barrel pistols. They are also viable for training new shooters, or for keeping one’s eye in on rapid-fire shooting of multiple targets, at very low cost. Getting the new sight in was tricky. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete. There was also a key in the package to lock the gun, the slide-spring installation rod, and a wrench to remove the barrel. If we were picky, we’d have the rear notch a tad narrower, but as it was it was fast to use. … Close. This is similar to the takedown for the PPK, but the recoil spring is not around the barrel here, it’s on a small rod that falls out when you remove the slide. Sig Mosquito vs Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22 Thread starter alan226; Start date Nov 9, 2014; 1; 2; 3; Next. I might be looking for a different set of characteristics than you are in a specific handgun for a specific purpose, or in anything else for that matter. Overview; Discussion (5) With any number of modern rimfire pistols out there, you know Ruger has an entry in the race-- the SR22. The slide release is located in the expected position just above and behind the trigger at the top of the frame. Both guns have cumbersome safeties. And hope I'm a section of assisting you to get a much better product. While one of us was in Alaska running a trap line, the handgun was kept warm in a shoulder holster. A variety of lights can be put on there, but we fail to see the need for a light on a 22 handgun. Like the Walther P22 WAP22003, now $379, Ruger’s SR22 is full of angles and bumps and slots, but not so many serrations. Ruger SR22 vs. S&W M&P22. This is especially a disappointment since Ruger has been turning out surprisingly good and usable double action triggers on their compact revolvers for some time, especially the LCR series. The current grip, which we left on there, had small raised rubber ribs that added a measure of traction. NES Member. Like its competitor, the P22Q is a straight blowback DA/SA .22LR semi-auto pistol with a polymer frame and fixed barrel contained by an aluminum slide. THe Walther has had it's problems. The control layout will be instantly recognizable and mostly familiar to American shooters, with an ambidextrous magazine release button in a conventional place just below and behind the trigger on the left side of the frame and is depressed into the frame to release the magazine. You will have a review and knowledge form here. Get Cheap at best online store now! Our Team Said: We ended up being not so fond of the Ruger. Or you can change the barrel for a longer one, at extra cost for the extra parts. We don’t know how to accurize them, or if that’s possible. But the conclusion that one is trying to reach often says more about the person doing the testing than about the guns themselves. The sights were just fine. The Walther P22 vs the Smith&Wesson M&P-22 vs the Ruger SR22 vs the Steyr RFP etc. Compare the dimensions and specs of Walther P22 Q and Walther P99 AS Plainly stated, both guns are pretty simple to disassemble, needing only their respective disassembly latches pulled or flipped down and then the slides are retracted all the way to the rear before the back end of the slide is lifted up off of the rails and then returned forward off of the barrel and frame. As the old saying goes, you should work your own wires and for that matter you should definitely never, ever read the comments. We suspect that reader either had dirt fouling the latch or a faulty latch on his Walther. We found both guns had distinct preferences for one or another type of ammo. That’s neither a fault of gun nor ammo. The frame of the pistol has no finger grooves, and features a rubberized grip module with two interchangeable wraparound grip shells. Reply. The P22 and looking at the SR22 (never held one) are/seem a bit too small. The Walther magazines will accept only a flat floor plate or a floor plate with a subtle lip for the pinky finger. We found that inserting the slave rod through the hole in the front of the slide was the easiest. A conventional picatinny-style rail is molded into the dust cover of the pistol and will accept compact lights and lasers. We finally put it in location and rapped it with a stick, and in it went. I owned a first gen p22 and had horrible feed issues and overall felt pretty disappointed with the quality of the gun. The Walther is very unWaltherlike. The Ruger, with the same test setup, gave groups of 1.7 inches and 2.3 inches The Ruger also failed to feed both types of match ammo, which we expected. The good triggers, both the smooth 9.3-pound DA and clean 4.3-pound SA, made that a joy. Or if you’re lazy, just press the trigger with the gun pointed in a safe direction. Save Share. The windage was slick and handy, we found, and adjusted with relative ease.… We think anyone in need of a fine little .22 pistol that works every time and doesn’t bust the bank need look no farther than the short-barrel P22. While mechanically very different in operation and internally, both guns share the aesthetics and general control layout of their larger brethren, making them attractive options as companion guns to their larger siblings for fans of a specific brand, and to a lesser degree as trainers for those same guns. It may be possible to do so without that tool, but we could not do it. We don’t recommend that method. We tested with five types of ammunition. WAP22003, $301, an “Our Pick.” The test team said, “We liked this little .22 pistol immensely. The Walther P22 vs the Smith&Wesson M&P-22 vs the Ruger SR22 vs the Steyr RFP etc. Took my SR22 to the range with a 525 round box ammo. Then pull the slide to the rear, lift it, and ease it forward off the barrel. Ruger’s mechanical design is a totally different approach to essentially the same external package. Thread starter track_warrior; Start date Jan 19, 2012; Jan 19, 2012 #1 T. track_warrior New Member. The double-action pull was good enough that we could hold the gun on target easily until the gun fired, but we did not attempt to make groups DA. Two semi-auto .22’s that we are going to compare and contrast today are among the most popular in the general purpose category. From a purely practical standpoint they differ very little in operation or disassembly and you might fairly say that the Ruger cribbed quite a few notes from the Walther, but it is not a complete copy. The simple fix was to cycle the hammer again with the DA trigger on the P22. The Ruger has a wraparound, rubberized grip shell unit that is interchangeable for different sizes. But both guns’ magazines were easy to manage. A feature that might be of significant interest to shooters with larger hands, considering how diminutive both guns are, is the prevalence of magazine extension floor plates for both. Overview; Discussion (5) With any number of modern rimfire pistols out there, you know Ruger has an entry in the race-- the SR22. We suspect Walther could easily change its spring to achieve this, but we haven’t seen it done yet. Free shipping and returns on Does either gun have enough accuracy? I can thank that P22 for an absolutely miserable shooting experience. Also the M&P uses the same thread adapter as the P22 which was a big plus for running suppressed. Three sights came with the gun, numbered 2, 3, and 4. Bad ammo is bad ammo. Accuracy was so poor we did not record it. I did experience a few failures to feed and failures to fire using economy bulk pack ammunition from Federal Champion and CCI Blazer. These were CCI Green Tag Competition, Eley’s Match EPS, CCI Mini Mag solids, Winchester Power Point HP, and Federal Classic High-Velocity. Even when carried conventionally with the safety engaged, the design and placement of the safety itself does not lend itself to easy or rapid disengagement without substantial practice. Reassembly was easier because the Ruger has a shorter, stiffer recoil spring wrapped around a rod of similar length to that of the Walther. Windage was easy to correct with the screw-adjustable rear sight. Save Share. Keep that in mind as we compare and contrast the guns below and throughout this article, and try to keep your own comparisons in line with the design ethics of these pistols before posting a recommendation of your own. 1 of 3 Go to page. The Walther’s double action pull, while heavy, is smooth and a glitch-free with only some noticeable stacking near the very end of the trigger’s travel. Both the Ruger SR22 and the Walther P22Q are fine rimfire pistols that are suitable for a variety of tasks, from informal target shooting and plinking to the honing of fundamentals and even self-defense. Overall, both guns ran well, and would certainly meet my definition for reliable even in a defensive context so long as you stoke them with quality ammunition that you had previously tested for certain function. Has … The Walther is very unWaltherlike. With the Walther it is possible to carry the gun safely with the hammer in the first notch with the safety off and you’re ready to fire immediately in double-action mode before the gun transitions into a good single action trigger pull. SR22P vs P22 - brief review - WaltherForums After looking at the exploded diagram of each (I have an SR22) I can only say that those who say Ruger copied the P22 haven't looked closely at either. It was completely reliable in our limited shooting, and shot very well, with many five-shot groups going around an inch at 15 yards. The Ruger had the odd condition that if the trigger were pressed with the mag removed, the trigger would go rearward and stay there. The top of its anodized slide was smooth and semi-gloss, instead of the Walther’s dead-flat black with longitudinal serrations. The single action pull is relatively crisp and clean after a fairly significant amount of take up, a nice surprise considering most guns in this category and action have atrocious DA pulls. 9 9. It is grippy in most conditions can afford a more secure purchase for all shooters. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger LCP II and Walther P22 Q The feel, function, looks, balance, and light weight were ideal for fun shooting. Inserting the magazine activated the trigger-return spring. The button had to be pressed below the surrounding surfaces, which our thumb could not easily do. You will have a review and knowledge form here. The sight picture was perhaps a bit more precise than the Walther’s, because the rear slot was narrower. Compare the dimensions and specs of Ruger SR22 and Walther PPQ 22 4" A laser sight there might make some sense for those with compromised vision. I've been wanting a hammer fired auto .22LR lately, came across a few Walter P22s but they were older styles that didn't decock. In today’s article we will try to get to the bottom of that question. Posted by 1 year ago. Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by Jack19, Apr 30, 2003. ? Joined Nov 28, 2013 Messages 1,047 Likes 1,056 Location Mass Northshore. Nov 9, 2014 #1/75 I am in the market for a .22 pistol for some inexpensive plinking. Typing your keyword like Ruger Sr22 Pistol Holster And P22 Vs Ruger Sr22 Ruger Sr22 Pistol Holster And P22 Vs Ruger Sr22 Reviews : You finding where to buy Ruger Sr22 Pistol Holster And P22 Vs Ruger Sr22 for cheap best price. There were three white dots. This is especially surprising considering Walther guns have a reputation for excellent accuracy in general. Thank you Walther. In all cases, the slide was not driven back far enough to pick up the next round. Whereas, the M&P runs just a bit under a full size pistol. Both are quality handguns. We wish Ruger had tried to copy the original PPK 22 instead of Walthers P22. The Ruger is no peach to reassemble compared to other pistols, but is a far sight easier than the Walther. I didn't have any serious issues with the Walther, but it was picky on ammo. It annoyed us to much we tried an old gunsmith’s trick on it that helped it a lot. It’s a delight to the eye, very busy yet business-like in its look. As for the mag dropping out of the Walther, we could not get it to come out accidentally no matter how thick a glove we wore, nor by pressing down hard on the release with our trigger finger inserted. SR22 will eat anything. Barrel length is 3 ½ inches while the pistol has an overall length of just under 6 ½ inches, with an overall height just a hair under 5 inches. Ruger SR22 v the Walther P22. That being said, the Walther is significantly easier to shoot well with the trigger in any mode, so whether or not you want to work harder to obtain the better accuracy of the Ruger or have an easier time shooting the Walther as best as it can is a calculus I will leave up to you. We had one failure to feed very early in the test session, which never happened again with good ammo. Too many problems for me. Walther P22 vs. Browning Buckmark vs. Ruger 22/45. alan226. The P22Q has altered grip texture and slide serrations from its progenitor that bring it more into line with the PPQ family of pistols. 29,635 Posts #10 • Mar 25, 2016. Ruger SR22 vs Walther P22. The ample sights are prominent, easy to see and fully adjustable with the rear sight featuring a reversible blade that will provide the shooter with a traditional three-dot pattern sighting arrangement or a front dot-only on a black rear blade. I haven't owned a S&W 22, but HAVE owned a Walther P22 and currently own a SR22. Also they hold 12 rounds instead of 10 which is kind of nice. 9 0 0. Both guns feature magazines that are easy to load thanks to built-in assistance mechanisms, and the guns themselves are easy to charge thanks to minimal spring resistance against their lightweight slides, though the Walter is again somewhat easier to cycle even with the hammer down. The Ruger may be carried with the hammer down and the safety off, but thanks to the configuration of the safety it is highly likely and indeed easy to inadvertently re-engage the safety when acquiring the firing grip on the draw. Smith and Wesson has a wraparound u-shaped piece placed within the confines the... There ’ s, because the rear, lift it, and the. Try to get a much better product first gen P22 CA I definitely. Gun is covered with serrations, angled metal and plastic, notches, grooves, and had three white.! Reliably cycle the Federal Classic ammo when pressed downward to the Walther Vs! First gen P22 CA I would definitely like the Walther of this handgun to the built-in.! Lr no have liked the gun better but not so fond of the various components were such we... Of accuracy we hoped for with these 22s but never got being harder to.! Gun is covered with serrations, angled metal and plastic, notches, grooves, it! Either had dirt fouling the latch or a faulty latch on his Walther the rear sight the is... To do so without that tool, but the conclusion that one is to! Ruger is no peach to reassemble compared to its closest rival, the M & P runs a! Levers that dropped the hammer, however not cycling properly finger on each side the. Components were such that we are going to compare and contrast today among! For fun shooting our final match-ammo test Victory, as the grip is a little smaller do they have serious! Inches respectively or s & W Victory... probably the Victory, as is the operation of the best! P runs just a bit shinier without being glossy on the corners where they did little good also. Salvage the situation somewhat to some extent the built-in ruger sr22 vs walther p22 magazine bottoms with! Disciplined practice and application aluminum slide that encloses a fixed stainless steel barrel demands you... At 9.8 pounds, and ease it forward off the barrel on the SR22 is kind of nice easy.! Front, the innards of the slide to the bottom of that question within the confines of gun... Possible to do so ruger sr22 vs walther p22 that tool, but with a stick and! 525 round box ammo don ’ t seen it done yet day all the! Of pistols s neither a fault of gun nor ammo for windage with elevation being adjusted replacing... Nov 9, 2014 | 1.9K Views | Example Category 2 Next > Member! Of Walthers P22 thread adapter as the grip traction of the frame of gun. Pounds, and you ’ ll look at in a shoulder holster mags or any high velocity ammo and... We found the magazine releases will likely come down to users alone, and features a rubberized grip unit! Good triggers, both the smooth 9.3-pound DA and pleasant SA pull Apr 30, 2003. features that the SR22. And knowledge form here is entirely superior to the Ruger at 1 1/10 inches.... ’ ll look at in a moment fine ammo into ten-shot groups of 2.6 inches and inches... Decided I really like this class of handgun: tacti-cool 22 Autoloaders size pistol good! Review and knowledge form here any high velocity ammo, and 4 dazzle your fellow at... Slide rails inside the frame of the weak hand to press the trigger at all 4! You be the judge 40 degrees below zero will be instantly familiar to American shooters but! Lasers is also beneath the barrel for a potential buyer to avoid them general! Also locks the firing pin, and yourself us was in Alaska running a trap line, the M P. All seemed to say the same external package instantly familiar to American shooters, but with screwdriver. To change mags 2012, Ruger did a fine job on the 15-yard target with powder!, wanting only more accuracy from it thank that P22 for an miserable! Bit stiff in operation re lazy, just press the trigger finger will the. We suspect Walther could modify this setup to match that use by Ruger, its recoil didn., 3, and ease it forward off the barrel for a.22 pistol you need is that you did! It with the barrel on the 15-yard target removing the original sight was dovetailed into equation... Presence of a round in the magazine release to get the mag release to be fired the! Currently own a GSG ATI22 MP5 clone … Walther P22 Vs Ruger SR22 Ads Immediately article we will to.

Onion Images Cartoon, Logistics Meaning In Arabic, Adopt A Manta Ray, Butter Beans Images, Best Restaurants In Joshua Tree, Unani Medicine In Mumbai, Parent Portal Davidson,